Home | Hindi | Kabir | Poetry | Workshop | BoloKids | Writers | Contribute | Search | Contact | Share This Page!                          Shop Online


  News
In Focus

Analysis  
Bolography  
Cartoons
Environment   
Opinion 

Columns
 Business
 
My Word 
 PlainSpeak 
 Random Thoughts 
Our Heritage

Architecture
Astrology
Ayurveda
Buddhism
Cinema 
Culture
Dances 
Festivals
Hinduism
History  
People  
Places 
Sikhism
Spirituality 
Vastu 
Vithika  

Society & Lifestyle

Family Matters 
Health
Parenting
Perspective 
Recipes
Society
Teens 
Women 

Creative Writings

Book Reviews
Ghalib's Corner
Humor
Individuality
Jagoji
Literary Shelf 
Love Letters  
Memoirs
Musings
Ramblings
Stories
Travelogues

Computing
  General Articles
 
CC++ 
  Flash 
  Internet Security 
 
Java 
 
Linux     
  Networking  

Health  
Don't Stop the Flow

by Gagandeep Kaur

For many a woman across the world, the recent US Food and Drug Administration (FDA) approval for Implanon - a contraceptive that could stop menstruation for up to three years - seems like the answer to many of her problems. She must strive to outperform her male colleagues at work to be recognized at par with them. There is no slack at home either, where running the home is primarily her job, as is taking care of the elderly or the ailing. And, let's face it, almost every woman has wished at some point that she could do away with menstruation.

For quite some time now, women have been popping the Pill to keep pregnancy at bay. Many have, in the process, discovered the joys of doing away with the menstrual cycle after the prolonged use of these hormonal contraceptive pills. Implanon, though, is something of a revolution. It is a single-rod contraceptive that is inserted under the skin in the upper arm and is effective for up to three years. No more popping the Pill or using barriers like condoms! A trained doctor inserts the rod five days after the onset of a monthly menstruation, and it is effective immediately.

Implanon is not yet available in India, but doctors in India are far from happy with this new development. In the US as well, Implanon has sparked off a debate on whether women should resort to menstruation suppression at all, especially for prolonged periods.

"For the past three years - after my marriage - I have been using oral contraceptives. Initially, there was some nausea and general weakness, but then it subsided. After about 18 months, I just stopped menstruating. My doctor said it is a side-effect of prolonged contraceptive pill use, and advised me to stop using the Pill for some time. But, frankly, I started enjoying the no-periods life," says Amol Bindra*, 32, a resident of Lajpat Nagar, New Delhi.

Doing away with menstruation for specific events - marriages, festivals or an activity - or to deal with the various demands at work and home is also an increasingly common phenomenon. "I had to go trekking once, and my gynecologist recommended a drug to alter the date of my periods. She also told me about contraceptives that, if taken regularly, can stop the menstruation cycle completely. After that, it sort of became a habit. I have now been using the Pill for almost two years and have not menstruated for almost a year. Of course, I have been told to stop using the Pill and not mess with my system, but it is too tempting, especially because I travel a lot," says Meenal Joshi, 27, a media professional in Delhi.

The medical fraternity, though, stresses that menstrual suppression has significant side-effects. "The most obvious side-effect of these contraceptives is that the lining of the uterus becomes thin. Many women experience nausea, weight gain and irritability. A number of studies also suggest that prolonged use of contraceptives could also lead to temporary infertility," says Dr Lalita Badhwar, gynecologist at Indraprastha Apollo Hospital, New Delhi.

She also cautions against another risk associated with implants: "Inserting implants in your body involves a minor surgical procedure. However, the implant may not agree with your system. This means you would have to go through another surgical procedure to remove it from your body. Implants are best avoided, and we do not recommend them in any circumstances."

Implanon is not currently available in India, but other implants - like Norplant, which works like Implanon and is also surgically implanted in the arm - were available until recently in government and other major private hospitals.
Norplant has also been surrounded by controversy ever since its launch. It has been available for trial in India since the 1980s, but many rural women reported side-effects like excessive bleeding and headaches. According to the website of the feminist organization 'INCITE! Women of Color Against Violence', about 3,500 Indian women were administered Norplant without screening to determine whether they were suitable candidates for the study. The study was finally stopped due to concerns about 'teratogenicity' and 'carcinogenicity'. The website also suggests that Norplant was disproportionately promoted among women of color, indigenous women and women with disabilities. It was withdrawn from the UK in 2001, and later from government hospitals in India as well. In any case, the reluctance of the medical fraternity to prescribe these implants ensured that they never became popular.

Leslie Botha - a US-based activist, author, women's health educator and radio and television talk show host, who campaigns against the increasing use of contraceptives to stop the menstruation cycle - says, "A major fallout of suppressing the endocrine system with the use of synthetic hormones for long periods of time is infertility. An increasing number of women are actually going into menopause in their 30s because they are unable to ovulate naturally. Their bodies are no longer able to produce natural hormones."

Botha also believes that often, the side-effects that women consider significant are deemed insignificant by the industry. She cites the example of birth control pill Enovid, which was introduced in the 1960s. "For Enovid, women in Puerto Rico, who were experimented on, had so many problems that the health officials were concerned about the pill. However, these concerns were ignored and the pill was pushed through the FDA," says Botha. Also, many products - like Norplant - are launched in the market without adequate research into the side-effects. "The industry is exploiting women in the name of 'choice'," she says.

An often-asked question is: Why this aversion to menstruation, a natural body process? There are no easy answers. Culturally, menstruation is construed as a negative - a messy process that needs to be hidden away. Even today, in several Indian families, menstruating women are not allowed to enter the kitchen, go to the temple or participate in certain festivals. Even for those not bound by tradition, menstruation does get in the way of many activities at work and home. In an ideal world, women would have a choice. But if it is not safe, it is not a choice.

"We have two fundamental concerns with extended and continuous combined hormonal contraceptives: the hype surrounding these new ways of taking hormonal contraceptives is focusing negative ideas about women by making normal menstruation into a problem; and the health implications of these more continuous ways of administering higher doses of estrogen and progestin are not yet known," says Jerilynn C Prior of the Centre for Menstrual Cycle and Ovulation Research, Vancouver, Canada on the Centre's website.

Prior even asks, "Have periods have become the latest of women's 'deficiencies'? Is having regular menstrual flow a 'Pill deficiency disease'?!"

(* The names of some women have been changed.)    

October 29, 2006

By arrangement with Women's Feature Service 

Top | Health  

The Week of October 29, 2006            
Will the PM Abet Corruption? by Rajinder Puri
US Elections and the Hell Shaped Curve by Gaurang Bhatt, MD  
United States Neurotic Obsessions
       with Pakistan's General Musharraf by Dr. Subhash Kapila
India's New Defence Minister:
      The Dilemma of Honesty or Efficiency
by Col. Rahul K. Bhonsle
Criminal Freedom versus Civil Thralldom by V. Sundaram 
Is England Becoming 'Little England'? by V. Sundaram 
Do They Speak ... These Statues? by Pradip Bhattacharya 
Death – An amazing phenomenon! by Pradeep Joshi
Beware! The Land Slides by VK Joshi
Home, Home On the (Nuclear) Range by Stephanie Hiller 
James Rennell: The Father of Indian Geography by Kumud Biswas
Michael Schumacher – the man and the champion by Yamini Ayyagari
Parenting with Love by Atasi Sen 
Love: A Pleasurable Pain by Julia Dutta
The Best of Both Worlds by Vikram Karve 
Chega Tchega Sega! by Naiya Sivaraj
The Witty Side by Melvin Durai 
America's Weakness by William R. Stimson 
The Global Village Is Tilted in America’s Favor by Glory Sasikala Franklin
I Want to be a Drop-out by Prakash Pathre
For the Sake of Laws by Aruni Mukherjee
Would Gandhi Win Today? by Rita Manchanda 
The State of Saffron by Elsa Sherin Mathews
Don't Stop the Flow by Gagandeep Kaur  
Bringing Health to their Doorstep by Sushmita Malaviya 
'I had an Abortion at Home' by Michelle R Bayaua
Mother's Recipe for Quality Schools by Malvika Kaul
 

 

Recommend This Page!

Analysis | Architecture | Astrology | Ayurveda | Book Reviews | Buddhism | Cartoons | Cinema | Computing | Culture | Dances
Environment | Fables | Family Matters | Festivals | Hinduism | Health | History | Home Remedies | Humor | Individuality | Jagoji
Literary Shelf | Memoirs | Musings | Opinion | Parenting | Perspective | Photo Essays | Places | Ramblings
Random Thoughts | Recipes | Sikhism | Society | Spirituality | Stories | Teens | Travelogues | Vastu | Vithika | Women

Home | Bolography | BoloKids | Columns | Hindi | Kabir | Poetry | Quotes | Workshop | Writers | Contribute | Search | Contact


Boloji.com is owned and managed by Boloji Media Inc
Privacy Policy | Disclaimer
No part of this Internet site may be reproduced without prior written permission of the copyright holder.